The Best Natural Diamond Jewels from the 2024 Tony Awards

Broadway mainstays and Hollywood’s finest came together for a night of theater and diamonds.

By |

Broadway’s biggest night, the Tony Awards, hosted by Ariana DeBose, brought out the stage’s hottest stars for a night of music, dance and everything theater, plus plenty of natural diamond moments. With more Hollywood stars turning to the stage to showcase their range of talents, the Tony Awards red carpet gets even more recognizable every year. From Elle Fanning to Succession’s Jeremy Strong, faces that usually appear on-screen are now on-stage.

Of course, the Tonys also saw some of Broadway’s biggest and brightest stars like Cynthia Erivo and Jonathan Groff, who just won his first Tony for his leading role in this year’s biggest show, Stephen Sondheim’s Merrily We Roll Along, co-starring Daniel Radcliffe and Lindsay Mendez.

Ahead, take a look at some of the best diamond-dressed stars on the red carpet at the 2024 Tony Awards in New York City.

Sarah Paulson

Getty Images

Paulson took home the Tony for Best Performance by an Actress in a Leading Role in a Play for her work in Appropriate. She wore bespoke shoulder duster earrings from Mindi Mond and a diamond and emerald ring from Reza.

Angelina Jolie

Getty Images

Jolie and her daughter Vivienne are both producers for one of Broadway’s newest shows, a musical adaptation of The Outsiders. Jolie attended the award ceremony wearing a Briony Raymond vintage yellow gold and natural diamond ring by Cartier.

Cynthia Erivo

Getty Images

A musical theater mainstay from the West End to Broadway, Erivo will be starring as Elphaba in the movie adaptation of Wicked this fall. She attended the Tony’s to present the Best Musical award with Idina Menzel, wearing Jean Schlumberger by Tiffany & Co natural diamond jewelry.

Erivo chose the Jean Schlumberger by Tiffany Leaves necklace in platinum and 18k yellow gold with diamonds along with the Five Leaves earrings, a yellow gold and diamond bracelet plus 5 natural diamond rings.

Rachel McAdams

Getty Images

McAdams also wore Tiffany & Co on the red carpet, including a Tiffany Lock bracelet, the Tiffany Edge earrings and bracelet, and Tiffany Soleste and Paloma Picasso® Melody rings.

Elle Fanning

Getty Images

Samantha McMillen styled Fanning in a sleek black Sant Laurent suit and simple but stunning natural diamond jewelry from Cartier including the Reflection de Cartier necklace.

Ariana DeBose

Getty Images

The show’s host kept it simple with her natural diamonds, opting for a pair of drop earrings from Rahaminov.

Jonathan Groff

Getty Images

The actor and now first-time Tony Award winner wore the famous Tiffany & Co Bird on a Rock brooch as a tie pin.

Taraji P. Henson

Getty Images

Henson wore head-to-toe Reza jewels, including yellow gold and natural diamond earrings and three natural diamond rings.

Jeremy Strong

Getty Images

Former Eldest Boy picked up his first Tony for Best Performance by an Actor in a Leading Role in a Play, Henrik Ibsen’s An Enemy Of The People, wearing a black diamond bracelet by Sidney Garber.

Bee Shaffer

Getty Images

The actress and Anna Wintour’s daughter wore antique Victorian diamond chandelier earrings and an antique Victorian Paste Necklace, both circa the 1880s, from Briony Raymond.

Lindsay Mendez

Getty Images

The Merrily We Roll Along star wore natural diamond jewels from Pasquale Bruni.

Kara Young

Getty Images

The actress, who won the Tony Award for Featured Actress in a Play, dripped in DeBeers natural diamonds, including a 31.57 Seven Line diamond necklace, 5.2-carat diamond studs and a 5.31-carat diamond cocktail ring.