< Culture & Style / Jewelry Trends
All Treats, No Tricks: Natural Diamond Halloween Jewelry
You’ll want to wear these 13 ghoulish jewels long after spooky season is over.
Updated: October 16, 2025
Written by: Anna McFillin
Halloween has enchanted people for more than 2,000 years, a celebration glittering with mystery, magic, and ritual. Born from the Celtic festival of Samhain, which marked the end of the harvest and the shift into winter, the holiday absorbed Roman influences and the solemn traditions of All Hallows’ Eve before transforming into the spirited celebration we know today. Costumes, candy, and adornment remain at its heart, and few things capture that sense of transformation and imagination more brilliantly than Halloween jewelry.
From ancient masks meant to ward off spirits to modern jewels that capture the imagination, adornment has always been part of Halloween’s magic. For me, jewelry has always been the most exciting part of Halloween. As a child, that meant plastic necklaces and stick-on earrings to bring a costume to life. Now, it means natural diamonds—pieces that outlast a single evening and hold the same enduring mystique that makes Halloween so intriguing. The costume is now the accent, and the jewelry is the centerpiece.
Meet the Expert
- Anna McFillin is an editor and jewelry lover who found her niche in the industry after working at Elle, InStyle, Grazia USA, and Only Natural Diamonds.
- Her favorite way to style natural diamonds is through her 13 (!) unique ear piercings.
- She writes feature stories, Q&A interviews, sustainability features, shopping guides, and red carpet coverage.
Natural diamonds carry their own kind of magic. Formed deep within the earth over billions of years, they embody endurance, transformation, and timeless beauty. These qualities align perfectly with Halloween’s spirit of mystery and rebirth, making diamonds the ultimate way to celebrate the season in style.
Ahead, discover Halloween jewelry with natural diamonds—and shop styles that sparkle well beyond October 31.
Creepy and Cosmic: Motifs That Define Halloween Jewelry
Look closely at spooky diamond jewelry and you’ll find some recurring themes, steeped in centuries of symbolism: reminders of death, gothic script, creepy-crawly creatures, and mystical details.
Skulls have long represented mortality and remembrance, from early Memento Mori jewelry—Latin for “remember death,” created to remind the wearer of life’s fragility—to the elaborate mourning jewels of the Victorian era, making them an enduring emblem of Halloween jewelry. Spiders and insects, often seen as both protective talismans and omens, also carry an eerie edge that feels perfectly suited to the season.
Snakes, beautiful in form yet capable of evoking a sense of danger, have been revered since antiquity as symbols of rebirth and immortality, their coiled shapes translating naturally into diamond rings and pendants. Celestial moons and stars add another mystical dimension, recalling astrology, seasonal rituals, and the ancient belief that the cosmos shaped human destiny. Reimagined in natural diamonds, these motifs blend history, mystery, and the supernatural into jewels that capture the spirit of Halloween in dazzling style.
Shop Spooky Chic Diamond Halloween Jewelry
Get inspired by diamond Halloween jewelry that’s both spell-binding and timeless. Skulls, serpents, celestial motifs, and make a seasonal statement with natural diamonds—no costume required.
David Yurman
No collection of spooky Halloween jewelry would be complete without a diamond skull pendant from David Yurman. The brand offers striking variations, from white or black diamond skulls accented with contrasting diamond eyes to a bold white diamond skull finished with fiery ruby eyes.
SHOP NOW: David Yurman Memento Mori Skull, $3,900, davidyurman.com
Modern Moghul
No collection of diamond Halloween jewelry would be complete without a spider. This Modern Moghul creation, set with glittering diamonds, ruby eyes, and a luminous baroque pearl, captures the perfect balance of eerie and elegant, ready to be added to any chain you choose.
SHOP NOW: Modern Moghul Makadee Charm, $800, modernmoghul.com
Sylva & Cie
This lifelike lapis skull from Sylva & Cie can be worn year-round. Gray diamond eyes and a star-spangled crown give this versatile pendant a perfectly haunting glow.
SHOP NOW: Sylva & Cie Superstar Skull Pendant, $10,000, shop.mitchellstores.com
Dries Criel
In ancient Egypt, the scarab was a powerful symbol of protection and eternal life. Dries Criel’s onyx and white diamond scarab ring channels that rich history, reimagined as a modern talisman.
SHOP NOW: Dries Criel Onyx Scarab Ring, $7,080, brokenenglishjewelry.com
Bernard James
Looking to infuse some dark fairytale magic into your Halloween jewelry style? Bernard James’s pavé mushroom ring dazzles with 400 hand-set white diamonds, transforming a woodland motif into something both enchanting and ultra-luxurious.
SHOP NOW: Bernard James Fungi Concia Diamond Ring, $9,900, bernardjames.com
State Property
I may not love spiders or the webs they spin, but I can’t resist these earrings from State Property. Inspired by Byzantine architecture with a subtle rock-and-roll edge, they echo the silhouette of a spider’s web in the most refined and unexpectedly chic way.
SHOP NOW: State Property Borsh Discus Enchantress Earrings, $ $5,680, thisisstateproperty.com
Single Stone
Initial necklaces may be a jewelry essential, but Single Stone’s diamond gothic letters are anything but basic. Rendered in dramatic Gothic script—a style of ornate lettering that first appeared in medieval manuscripts—these customizable pendants bring a bold, old-world edge to a modern classic, ready to shine on any chain.
SHOP NOW: Single Stone Large Cobblestone Letter, $7,500, Price Upon Request, shopsinglestone.com
Eva Fehren
Eva Fehren’s blackened gold and white diamond Dagger Pendant brings a cloak-and-dagger allure to fine jewelry. Sharp, sleek, and a little dangerous, it’s the perfect piece of diamond Halloween jewelry to add intrigue to your everyday look.
SHOP NOW: Eva Fehren Dagger Pendant, $2,775, evafehren.com
Foundrae
In Victorian jewelry, snake rings symbolized eternal love and wisdom; their coiled forms were a token of devotion. Foundrae’s diamond serpent ring reimagines that symbolism with a modern sentiment, its pavé body seeming to slither as it wraps elegantly around your finger. It’s both a charming addition to your ring stack or can be worn on its own.
SHOP NOW: Foundrae Snake Diamond Pave Bookend Band, $6,200, foundrae.com
Brent Neale
Brent Neale’s skull-and-crossbone diamond earrings add just the right touch of irreverence. Perfect for Halloween jewelry season or any day you want to channel that bold “not today” energy, they are equal parts playful and elevated.
SHOP NOW: Brent Neale Not Today Studs, $3,250, brentneale.com
Ali Weiss
For centuries, the moon has been seen as a source of powerful energy, tied to divine femininity, intuition, and renewal. Ali Weiss’s diamond moon charm channels that symbolism in shimmering white diamonds, serving as both a protective talisman and a reminder of the powerful properties found in natural diamonds.
SHOP NOW: Ali Weiss Diamond Moon Charm, $950, aliweissjewelry.com
Nicole Rose
Hoops may be a jewelry classic, but Nicole Rose gives them a dark seasonal twist. Her onyx and double diamond design creates a daring contrast, making these earrings a striking choice for diamond Halloween jewelry and beyond.
SHOP NOW: Nicole Rose Diamond and Onyx Double Hoop Earrings, $8,950, nicolerosejewelry.com
